Can You Use a Stick Welder for TIG Welding?
TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) and Stick welding are both widely used welding processes, but can a stick welder be used for TIG welding? Many welders, especially beginners, wonder if their existing stick welding machine can be adapted for TIG welding. The answer is yes—with some limitations. This guide explores how it works, the necessary modifications, and when it’s a practical option.
Understanding Stick and TIG Welding
What is Stick Welding?
Stick welding, also known as Shielded Metal Arc Welding (SMAW), uses a consumable electrode coated with flux to create an arc that melts the base metal. The flux produces a shielding gas that protects the weld pool from contaminants, making it a versatile and widely used process.
What is TIG Welding?
TIG welding (Gas Tungsten Arc Welding or GTAW) uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode to create an arc, while an external shielding gas (typically argon) protects the weld area. TIG is known for producing precise and high-quality welds but requires more skill and control.
Can a Stick Welder Be Used for TIG?
The short answer is yes, but with some modifications and limitations. Many stick welders, especially those with DC output, can be used for scratch-start TIG welding.
Requirements for Using a Stick Welder for TIG Welding
- DC Output: The stick welder must have DC output, as AC-only welders are not compatible with TIG welding.
- TIG Torch with Gas Valve: Since stick welders lack built-in gas control, a torch with a manual gas valve is necessary.
- Argon Gas Supply: TIG welding requires shielding gas, typically delivered through a regulator and hose connected to the TIG torch.
- Scratch Start Technique: Unlike dedicated TIG machines with high-frequency start, using a stick welder for TIG requires a scratch-start technique to initiate the arc.
- Electrode Holder Removal: The standard stick welding electrode holder is not needed. Instead, a TIG torch is connected to the negative terminal, and the work clamp is attached to the positive terminal.
How to Set Up a Stick Welder for TIG Welding
- Turn Off the Welder: Always start by turning off and unplugging the welder before making any modifications.
- Attach the TIG Torch: Connect the TIG torch to the negative terminal (DCEN – Direct Current Electrode Negative) for better heat concentration and penetration.
- Set Up the Gas Flow: Connect the shielding gas cylinder to the torch through a regulator and hose.
- Secure the Work Clamp: Attach the work clamp to the positive terminal.
- Choose the Right Tungsten Electrode: Use a 2% thoriated tungsten electrode for steel and stainless steel welding.
- Start Welding: Use the scratch-start method to initiate the arc, being careful not to contaminate the tungsten.
Limitations of Using a Stick Welder for TIG Welding
While a stick welder can be used for TIG, it has some drawbacks:
- No Foot Pedal or Adjustable Amperage Control: TIG machines allow for precise heat control, which is lacking in a stick welder.
- Limited to DC Welding: You cannot weld aluminum effectively without an AC power source, which most stick welders lack.
- Less Smooth Arc Start: Without high-frequency start, scratch-starting the arc can be challenging and may contaminate the tungsten.
- No Post-Flow Gas Control: Dedicated TIG welders manage gas flow before and after the arc stops, which helps protect the weld pool.
When Does It Make Sense to Use a Stick Welder for TIG?
Using a stick welder for TIG welding is practical when:
- You need to weld mild steel or stainless steel.
- Precision isn’t the top priority.
- You already own a stick welder and want to experiment with TIG before investing in a dedicated machine.
- You don’t need features like high-frequency start or a foot pedal.
Conclusion
A stick welder can be used for TIG welding with a few modifications, but it won’t replace a dedicated TIG welding machine. If you need precise, high-quality welds, investing in a proper TIG welder is the best option. However, for occasional TIG welding on steel or stainless steel, adapting a stick welder can be a cost-effective solution.
Related Articles You Might Find Helpful
For more insights on welding techniques and equipment, check out these related articles.
